Most start-up disputes in India do not begin with fraud. They begin with silence: nobody wrote down who decides what, how shares can be sold, what happens when one founder leaves or how an investor exits. A shareholders’ agreement (SHA) fills that silence. It is a contract among the shareholders and, usually, the company. It sits on top of the Companies Act, 2013, and the company’s Articles of Association, and it sets the commercial rules of the relationship.
This guide explains what an SHA does, how it differs from the Articles, the twelve clauses that matter most, the drafting mistakes we see in Gurugram deals, and when you should involve a lawyer. If you have not yet incorporated, read our guide to company registration in Gurugram first.
SHA vs Articles of Association: why you need both
The Articles of Association (AoA) are a public document filed with the Registrar of Companies. They bind the company and its members. The SHA is private and binds only the parties who sign it. A well-advised company aligns the two: the key protections in the SHA are incorporated into the AoA, so that the company itself is bound by them and so that a conflicting article cannot be used against the SHA. If the SHA and AoA conflict, the position can become uncertain, and a court may give effect to the AoA over the contract, so alignment is essential. For private companies, restrictions on share transfer in the Articles are a standard feature. For public companies, the Companies Act now makes certain contracts on transfer of securities enforceable as contracts, but you should check the current position with your lawyer before relying on it.
The twelve clauses that matter most
1. Capital structure and use of funds
The agreement should state the shareholding at signing, the amount invested, the price per share and how the money is to be used. An investor who is promised growth spending should be able to see that the funds are not diverted to founder loans or unrelated ventures.
2. Board composition and nominee directors
Who sits on the board, how many nominees each investor can appoint and whether an independent director is required. Control of the board is control of the company. Make sure the quorum rules do not allow one side to block a meeting by staying away.
3. Reserved matters (affirmative voting rights)
A list of decisions that require the consent of a specified investor or class of shareholders, even if the board approves them. Typical examples are changes to the Articles, issuing new shares, taking on debt beyond a limit, selling a major asset, changing the business, approving the annual budget, hiring or firing key executives and related-party transactions. Founders should negotiate the list carefully, because a long list gives the investor day-to-day veto power.
4. Pre-emptive rights and anti-dilution
Pre-emptive rights let existing shareholders subscribe to new shares in proportion to their holding, so they are not diluted without a chance to invest. Anti-dilution clauses protect an investor if the company later issues shares at a lower price. These can be “full ratchet” or “weighted average” structures, and the difference to founders can be large.
5. Right of first refusal (ROFR) and right of first offer (ROFO)
Under a ROFR, if a shareholder wants to sell to a third party, the other shareholders must first be offered the shares on the same terms. A ROFO works differently: the selling shareholder must first offer the shares to the other shareholders before approaching third parties. These clauses keep outsiders out of the cap table.
6. Tag-along and drag-along rights
A tag-along right lets minority shareholders join a sale by the majority on the same terms, so they are not left behind with a new controlling shareholder. A drag-along right allows a majority, or an agreed percentage of shareholders, to force the minority to sell when a buyer wants 100 per cent of the company. Drag-along clauses need thresholds, minimum price protections and conditions on warranties, otherwise they can be used oppressively.
7. Lock-in and transfer restrictions
Founders usually agree not to sell shares for a defined period. Investors may have more freedom to transfer. Permitted transfers, for example to a family trust or an affiliate, should be defined to avoid disputes.
8. Founder vesting and leaver provisions
Founder shares typically vest over several years, with a cliff. A “good leaver” and “bad leaver” regime sets out what happens to the founder’s shares if she or he leaves, and at what price they are bought back. Without this, a co-founder who leaves in year one can hold a large share of equity forever.
9. Non-compete, non-solicit and confidentiality
Be realistic about enforceability. Under Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, agreements in restraint of trade are void, and Indian courts generally do not enforce post-termination non-competes against employees. Restrictions that operate while a person remains a shareholder or director are more likely to be upheld, and confidentiality and non-solicitation of employees and customers are commonly enforced when reasonable. Draft these clauses with enforceability in mind rather than copying a foreign template.
10. Information and inspection rights
Investors should receive monthly management accounts, annual audited financials, budgets and prompt notice of litigation. Founders should clarify confidentiality and who can access sensitive information.
11. Exit mechanisms
How and when can investors realise their investment? Options include an IPO within a stated period, a strategic sale, a buy-back, a put option to founders or a call option. In businesses with foreign investors, FEMA pricing guidelines and sectoral rules affect these clauses, and options must be structured carefully. Make sure the exit clause is realistic: a founder who cannot afford to buy out the investor will not be helped by a put option on paper.
12. Deadlock, governing law and dispute resolution
Deadlock occurs when shareholders with equal votes cannot agree. The SHA should provide a ladder: escalation to senior management, mediation, then a buy-sell mechanism or a “Texas shoot-out”, and finally an exit. Choose the governing law and a dispute resolution forum. Most commercial SHAs provide for arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, with a seat in Delhi or Gurugram and a sole arbitrator or panel of three. A clear arbitration clause helps avoid years of litigation. See our arbitration lawyer services.
Other clauses worth considering
- ESOP pool and approval process for grants.
- Key person provisions and insurance.
- Warranties and indemnities by founders and the company.
- Conditions precedent and subsequent to funding, such as completing legal due diligence or obtaining statutory approvals.
- Compliance undertakings including anti-bribery, tax and labour law. Employers must also meet workplace obligations such as the POSH Act, and investors increasingly ask for evidence of compliance in due diligence.
- Intellectual property ownership by the company. See our IP practice.
Common drafting mistakes
- Copying a template from the internet or from a foreign jurisdiction without adapting it to Indian law.
- No alignment with the Articles, so the company is not bound.
- Vague reserved matters that cause disputes over what needs consent.
- No vesting for founders.
- Unrealistic exit clauses that cannot be performed in practice.
- Ignoring stamp duty. An SHA must be stamped in accordance with the state’s stamp law, and an unstamped document can be inadmissible until duty and penalty are paid.
- Ignoring regulatory approvals for foreign investment or sectoral limits.
- Silent on deadlock, leaving only litigation as a remedy.
When should you sign an SHA?
Ideally at the time of the first outside investment, and for co-founders, as early as incorporation. Waiting until a dispute arises means negotiating when trust is gone. A short founders’ agreement at day one, later replaced by a full SHA at the first funding round, is a common and sensible path. Our contract drafting and vetting services are designed for exactly this.
Practical negotiation tips for founders
- Know which terms are standard and which are aggressive. Not every investor ask is market practice.
- Focus on control terms (board, reserved matters, liquidation preference) more than on valuation alone.
- Model the consequences of anti-dilution and liquidation preference on a sample exit.
- Ask for clarity on what happens at each future funding round.
- Keep the document readable. If you cannot explain a clause to your co-founder, revisit it.
Frequently asked questions
Is an SHA mandatory?
No. But without one, you rely only on the Companies Act and the Articles, which do not address most commercial arrangements.
Can an SHA override the Companies Act?
No. Any term that conflicts with mandatory provisions of law is unenforceable to that extent.
Who are the parties to the SHA?
Usually the company, the founders and the investors. Having the company as a party helps with enforcement.
Is the SHA the same as a term sheet?
No. A term sheet summarises key commercial terms and is mostly non-binding, apart from clauses such as confidentiality and exclusivity. The SHA is the binding contract.
Work with an advocate who understands the deal
Advocate Kanika Rao advises founders, investors and family-owned businesses in Gurugram on shareholders’ agreements, founder arrangements and disputes. Read about our corporate law services and contact us to review or draft your agreement. Also read our guide on annual compliance for private limited companies to plan the filings that follow an investment.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice.
